Pizza restaurants

Santino's Pizza - Oakfield

4.5 329 reviews 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM 2 Main St, Oakfield, NY 14125, United States

Discover this place

Santino's Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 2 Main St, Oakfield, NY. The menu features a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas, including popular options like pepperoni, extra cheese with mushrooms, and bacon chicken finger. Beyond pizza, the menu offers a range of sides such as chicken tenders, fries, fried dough, and cheese sticks. Diners can also find a selection of dinners featuring chicken, fish, and shrimp. Additional offerings include sandwiches and hoagies like the Italiano, as well as classic American options such as hamburgers and meatballs. The atmosphere at Santino's Pizza is casual, making it suitable for families and groups looking for a straightforward dining experience centered around familiar comfort foods. The restaurant stands out for blending classic pizza fare with an extensive variety of sides and entrees, providing options for diverse tastes in a local setting.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Santino's Pizza - Oakfield before visiting.

Reviews for Santino's Pizza - Oakfield

4.5

329 reviews

100%

17%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 329 reviews

Santino's Pizza in Oakfield, NY, is widely recognized for its consistently high-quality, fresh ingredients and flavorful offerings that often exceed customer expectations. Reviewers frequently highlight the pizza’s authentic taste, with some noting a nostalgic resemblance to renowned Chicago-style spots. The restaurant’s welcoming atmosphere and personable, friendly staff contribute to a positive dining experience, whether customers choose delivery, takeout, or dine-in options. The community-oriented vibe and reliable service make Santino's a favored local staple. Overall, feedback points to Santino's Pizza as a dependable destination for both locals and travelers seeking genuinely satisfying pizza in a cheerful, approachable setting.

Glenn Simmons

Jul 10, 2025

Fantastic food great service!!!! Reminded me of pizza spots in Chicago.

Lonnie Clere

May 30, 2025

Many people have told me to go to many different pizza places, they swore there pizza was the best, and everytime I tryed one i was disappointed because to me, it’s taste like an average pizza you can pick up from a store, But me and my wife decided to stop at this place called santinos in Oakfield New York and for the first time in my 6 years of living in New York I finally found a place that the pizza taste absolutely amazing and taste like a fresh baked pizza. So thank you for the great tasting food. I’ll be back to try everything else.

Relyn Li

May 29, 2025

We made a stop on the way to Rochester, the pizza was beyond our expectations. We asked for extra cheese the quality and taste overall were amazing. Staffs were also friendly!!!!!

Miranda Fuller

May 01, 2025

Santinos is a wonderful pizza shop. It is a staple of this small community. You can't go wrong with their pizza, it's delicious. They offer delivery, pick up, and dining in. The staff is great, very personable, and easy to crack a few jokes with.

Toni Amanda Cowell

Apr 28, 2025

Just discovered this place after stopping by the dealership next door. They have the best pizza I’ve had in the 6 years I lived in NY! Everything is fresh & taste amazing. The sheet pizza is huge!

Esa U

Apr 16, 2025

The royal sub with everything on it is PHENOMENAL! The pizza is delicious but the crust is pretty thick. The pizza sauce is actually pretty flavorful, too! The wings are very good quality and super saucey. The customer service from all the team members was laid-back yet attentive. They went above and beyond to ensure my partner and I had a great experience! My first visit was on valentine's day but the experience was so awesome, I'm going back again today! I definitely recommend this place. It's the best pizza I've found since moving to ny!